Lurky McLurklurk (ionlylurkhere) wrote,
Lurky McLurklurk
ionlylurkhere

Shortest squee-to-harshed-squee transition EVAH

So, over in a comment in doctorwho, doyle_sb4 mentioned "the upcoming IDW comic" of DW. Which I had not heard about before, and the news made me all kinds of squeeful.

Then I Googled for more info.


It's being written by Gary Russell. Who ... well, I don't have many nice things to say about Gary Russell, and I'm in the sort of mood where I want to provide a bit of positive balance to anything negative I say, so I'm just going to not say anything. (EsomewhatlaterTA: though I have just had an epiphany that having spent years boggling at the people who have such a downer on JNT and RTD, I feel about Gary Russell pretty much exactly the way they do about those producers.)

And it's basically missing adventures from the second half of S3 (same as the Ten/Martha books essentially). Which means if we get any shippiness at all, we're going to have to handle the unrequited again. Though to be honest, I doubt there'll be much shippiness. (Hmm. There's a rumour, or maybe just a strongly-held wish, that they realise the unrequited was a mistake, so maybe they'll use the comic as a chance to try and suggest it's not as bad as it seemed on TV, but unless it's done very well that'll just make it harder to watch the TV eps.)

And heaven knows I'm no great art critic, but I'm not hugely convinced by the sketches on that CBR page either. I don't demand photo-realism in mah spinoff comics (or I wouldn't love Jeanty's work in Buffy S8 so much), but some of the poses seem to suggest they're the Stretch Armstrong doll versions of Ten'n'Martha.


Ah, well, it's not like I haven't got the graphic novels of the DWM comics to sigh over. God, Izzy's great.

I'm probably still going to buy it every month on the day of release though.
Tags: comics, doctor who
Subscribe

  • :D

    Usually the music round is the low point for me with University Challenge, but this week's was awesome. (It was '60s TV themes. The Saint, The Priz,…

  • It is that telly meme

    From everyone pretty much but I did my c-and-p from cakesy: Name a TV show series in which you have seen every episode at least twice:…

  • Telleh

    So there has been quite a lot of fannish-type telly while I've been semi-away. I am going to pretend that you care what I thought of it. Planet of…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments