Lurky McLurklurk (ionlylurkhere) wrote,
Lurky McLurklurk
ionlylurkhere

meandering sort-of-venting-but-mostly-comics post

God, I'm in a cranky mood. If I was inclined to, I could write wanky multi-thousand-word posts on pretty much every single story in the news this week. About the best thing that can be said is that at least academies have been shown not to work, but thousands of children continuing to be failed by the system would only really constitute good news if at least it meant they were going to stop letting any old nutters with cash to splash indoctrinate them, which it won't.

I'm even being got down by the BBC's wonderfully comprehensive coverage of the 150 years of the Origin/Darwin bicentenary thing, because when they put this much emphasis on Darwin I just see it playing into the hands of the creationists who can't see the difference between prophets and scientists.

Er, anyway, there were new comics today. That's what I originally came here to say. If you are a comics-y person, be warned there are spoilers.

Captain Britain and MI-13 #9 There is a lot to love about this comic. Leonard Kirk does a wonderful job with the interdimensional bits, perfectly capturing the feel of the '60s Ditko Doctor Strange, which is only right and fitting for a story with Mindless Ones in it, while blending it with his own style so that it doesn't look at all out of place in the comic overall, which is quite the achievement. And there are some wonderful bits of dialogue, particularly Brian realising that Alastaire isn't his heart's desire. But, and it's a very big but, there are some key plot points that do violence to the characterisations. Now admittedly, these aren't characters I know outside of Cornell's take on them in Wisdom but he made me fall hard for them there and he doesn't get to make Sid a traitor or Pete a I-despise-you-but-you-used-to-be-my-friend-so-you-can-have-a-gun-to-kill-yourself-with type without me getting upset. I'm sure there are all sorts of arguments in favour of it both as gritty drama and in-character, but it's just so horribly, horribly grim and feels completely unnecessary and I suspect there's at least one person on my flist who's going to be even unhappier than me.

Nova: The Origin of Richard Rider This is a clip show, basically, with Nova's origin comic and his first superhero team up (with Thor, who is mind controlled so that they can fight before teaming up, because it is 1976 when all's said and done) sandwiched between bread-of-a-few-new-pages. The reprinted comics feel weird to me - they're very similar to '60s comics in style and tone, but somehow even without glaring context stuff it feels naive in a way that the Silver Age stuff doesn't. There's sort of a sense that the writers are writing down, maybe, whereas Stan Lee always strikes you as really being exactly as daft and enthusiastic as he sounds? BTW I'm not valorising the Dark Knight Returns/Watchmen axis particularly here; even the early '80s Claremont/Byrne X-Men is heaps better than this, and Claremont's writing has hundreds of issues. The most lulsy thing is that the similarities to Green Lantern are even more transparently obvious than I would have guessed, from the dying alien passing on his legacy to the green beam that seeks out Richard.

Booster Gold #16 This comic seems to have lost its way a bit since the changeover in creative teams, but this issue helped me put my finger on why: the time travel stuff has become far too teleological. Here we have an Egyptian knife that was only tangential to the plotline it was originally involved in "drawing Booster through time". It may just be a side effect of the decision to take Rip Hunter out of the picture, given that he was Basil Exposition, but it's a view of how time travel works that I can't really get behind on a gut-instinct level. Booster is not Sam Beckett. Go away, crossover plotbunny. Anyway, this is part of "Faces of Evil", which apparently means we get slightly strange covers and a few thought balloons from the bad guy. Booster appears in WWI, meets Enemy Ace, who is a Good German but still allows him to be tortured so, er, yeah, not sure what that was meant to mean, and the big twist is that he saved Maxwell Lord's ancestor's life. Which is a good idea, except that it emphasises Max's retcon into pure evil. Now I am a latecomer to decrying this, because OMAC Project was one of my gateway drugs for the DCU in general, but after enjoying JLI so much I like him there with his trying-to-better-himself thing. Again, I suspect this is going to make one of my flist annoyed but he's unlikely to read it so I sort of hope he doesn't read this either.

Final Crisis #6 Half of Jaime was in two whole panels! And he got an entire speech balloon! Unfortunately, it says "I need some help over here!" rather than the sort of spectacularly awesome thing Jaime should be saying, but at least he's with Alan Scott Green Lantern, which is cool.

Bias aside, I was a bit disappointed with this overall, but really only because Grant Morrison is interested in lots of different bits of the DCU and the ones he focuses on this time round are ones that I just don't care about that much. (In particular, I have shockingly little time for Bats, and even less for Captain Marvel and family, though I can appreciate the use of Tawky Tawny on the intellectual level.) Last issue had lots of Lanterny goodness, but here they're just trapped unable to get back to Earth.

Morrison is very good at nonsensical technobabble that sounds right, I envy him that quite a bit. Darkseid killed Batman, so at least they weren't kidding around with all the RIP stuff I suppose, and then Clark flew in and grabbed him and it was quite slashy for a moment at the end there and you sort of forget how close their relationship is given how they often represent diametrically opposed tones (Skience vs Grim and Gritty I think). Actually, I have little time for either of them individually and almost none at all for their supporting casts, but as icons they work very well and that tension between where they're coming from makes their relationship great.

GLC 32 In which it turns out yet again that the Guardians are idiots, but pleasingingly a lot of Lanterns are sensible about it and quit in disgust! Kyle needs to rent the Guardians the Star Wars prequel trilogy, I think, once Earth comes out of Darkseid's Personal Singularity ('cos all these comics are happening at once, obv), and when George Lucas can expose the flaws in your plan it might be time to reevaluate quite how omniscient and omnipotent and such you think you are. Interesting that Kyle and Soranik are open with each other about what they saw in the Star Sapphire's Shippy Plot Device Helmet, but it makes me ship them less, because I turn out to be annoyingly contrarian. Kryb's Faces-of-Evil bit in this is even more pastede-on-yay than in Booster Gold, which is saying something. It's a shame because if they'd developed it a bit further it could have been an intriguing take on maternal instinct and stuff.

On the reasons-to-be-cheerful front, on my way back from my LCS I passed a charity shop that had the little collection of the very first Bridget Jones columns that the Indy put out back in 2005 when they got Helen Fielding to come back to them with it. And so I bought it for 50p, and restrained myself from squeeing at the bored teenager behind the till as I did so (I was half tempted to squee at the sheer existence of volunteering-bored-teenager, but never mind). It has the proper Bridget who was at the top of the column on the cover and everything, not any of these fake Bridgets, and has made me very nostalgic for my school library where I used to read them every whichever-day-of-the-week-it-was-but-I'm-fairly-sure-it-started-with-a-T. I am almost scared in case they turn out not to be as good as I remember.

Er, anyway. As you can see, I'm feeling pretty cranky, though writing this has mellowed me out a bit which was kind of the point because otherwise this was going to segue into My Thoughts on Fanfic Awards. But I could still do with a bit of a pick-me-up. Drabble Ficlet prompt me, pretty pls? (Who, Whedon, or anything that's mentioned here.)

ETA: And here's a good reason to be cheerful I'd forgotten: I'm going to see this next month. Apparently it is not actually that good, but hey.
Tags: bridget jones related posts 1 (vg), comicses, the state of edumacashun
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 14 comments